Melanoma patients want to know! What do I choose? Targeted or immunotherapy? What happens then?

We melanoma patients all want to know!  Should I opt for targeted or immunotherapy?  What happens to me during treatment?  What happens after?  While there are no absolutes, here are some reports that attempt to provide a few answers.

TARGETED THERAPY:

The first addresses outcomes in Stage III/IV patients treated with the targeted therapy combo, Dabrafenib plus trametinib:

Five-Year Outcomes with Dabrafenib plus Trametinib in Metastatic Melanoma.  Robert, Grob, Stroyakovskiy, et al.  N Engl J Med. 2019 Jun 4. 

Patients who have unresectable or metastatic melanoma with a BRAF V600E or V600K mutation have prolonged progression-free survival and overall survival when receiving treatment with BRAF inhibitors plus MEK inhibitors. However, long-term clinical outcomes in these patients remain undefined. To determine 5-year survival rates and clinical characteristics of the patients with durable benefit, we sought to review long-term data from randomized trials of combination therapy with BRAF and MEK inhibitors.

We analyzed pooled extended-survival data from two trials involving previously untreated patients who had received BRAF inhibitor dabrafenib (at a dose of 150 mg twice daily) plus MEK inhibitor trametinib (2 mg once daily) in the COMBI-d and COMBI-v trials. The median duration of follow-up was 22 months (range, 0 to 76). The primary end points in the COMBI-d and COMBI-v trials were progression-free survival and overall survival, respectively.

A total of 563 patients were randomly assigned to receive dabrafenib plus trametinib (211 in the COMBI-d trial and 352 in the COMBI-v trial). The progression-free survival rates were 21% (17 to 24) at 4 years and 19% (15 to 22) at 5 years. The overall survival rates were 37% (33 to 42) at 4 years and 34% (30 to 38) at 5 years. In multivariate analysis, several baseline factors (e.g., performance status, age, sex, number of organ sites with metastasis, and lactate dehydrogenase level) were significantly associated with both progression-free survival and overall survival. A complete response occurred in 109 patients (19%) and was associated with an improved long-term outcome, with an overall survival rate of 71% (62 to 79) at 5 years.

First-line treatment with dabrafenib plus trametinib led to long-term benefit in approximately one third of the patients who had unresectable or metastatic melanoma with a BRAF V600E or V600K mutation.

Here are some links to earlier posts on the subject:
2014:  BRAF inhibitors for melanoma: Dabrafenib, Vemurafenib, Dabrafenib/trametinib combo. Answers!!!!!

2015:  BRAFi: What predicts resistance? Discontinuation after complete remission? Dabrafenib/trametinib combo and quality of life?

2016:  Factors predictive of response, progression and OS with dabrafenib and trametinib

Also from 2016:  ASCO 2016 - Cobimetinib and Vermurafenib - coBRIM study

IMMUNOTHERAPY:

For comparison to the targeted therapy outcomes above, here's a report on immunotherapy from the dark ages of 2014:  Review of immunotherapy and durable benefit in melanoma!!!

This report documents the 4 year outcomes for ipi/nivo vs nivo alone for melanoma patients from December 2018:  CheckMate 067 - 4 year outcomes for nivo/ipi combo vs nivo alone in melanoma patients 

2019:  IPI/NIVO - results - in melanoma brain mets and long term follow-up in advanced melanoma

LOS DOS:

Here is a report from this year (with many links within) on combining targeted and immunotherapy:
Treating melanoma by COMBINING targeted therapy AND immunotherapy!!

HOW RATTIES REPORT THEY WERE AFFECTED BY EITHER TREATMENT:

Here are the results of a survey of 105 melanoma patients treated with either immunotherapy or BRAF/MEK who had an "objective response or stable disease" and were asked about the impact of said treatment on their lives:

The survivorship experience for patients with metastatic melanoma on immune checkpoint and BRAF-MEK inhibitors.  Lai-Kwaon, Khoo,Lo, et al.  J Cancer Surviv. 2019 Jun 4. 

Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) and BRAF and MEK inhibitors (BMi) have improved survival in metastatic melanoma (MM). However, the experience of long-term responders remains undescribed. This study characterised survivorship issues faced by long-term responders to ICI or BMi.

Patients with MM, aged greater than/equal to 18 years old, greater than/= to 6 months post-ICI or BMi initiation with an objective response or stable disease. A 72-question survey assessed physical and psychological effects, impact on lifestyle, access to information, satisfaction with care, and availability of supports.

One hundred and five of 120 (88%) patients completed the survey (ICI 69/BMI 36). For the ICI cohort, 39 (57%) were receiving ongoing treatment, 17 ceased due to toxicity and 13 due to a sustained response. For the BMi cohort, 31 (85%) were receiving ongoing treatment, 4 ceased due to toxicity and 1 due to a sustained complete response. At data cut-off on 18 December 2018, median PFS (range) was 2.5 years (1.3-8.5) for ICI and 3.1 years (0.6-7.3) for BMi. Long-term toxicities included dry/itchy skin (ICI 51, 74%/ BMi 25, 69%), arthralgias (ICI 30, 58%/ BMi 23, 64%) and fatigue (ICI 62, 90%/ BMi 33, 92%). Psychological morbidity was common, including anxiety awaiting results (ICI 50, 72%/ BMi 29, 81%), fear of melanoma recurring or progressing (ICI 56, 81%/ BMi 31, 86%) or death (ICI 44, 64%/ BMi 26, 72%).

MM survivors experience chronic treatment toxicities and frequently report psychological concerns.  Survivors may benefit from discussions regarding long-term toxicities and tailored psychological supports

WHAT TREATMENT TO CHOOSE:

If you are lucky enough to be a BRAF positive melanoma patient (about 1/2 of us) you have the option of targeted therapy or immunotherapy.  But picking which therapy to utilize is really tough for melanoma patients.

Here is some advice from some Melanoma Big Dogs in 2015:  Pick your poison: Weber and Agarwala discuss combination therapy for melanoma

Some advice on sequencing from 2018:  ASCO 2018 - Optimal sequencing of anti-PD-1 and BRAFi in Stage III patients

This post includes a report on what ratties have to consider re immunotherapy:  Balancing the Hype with Reality: What Do Patients with Advanced Melanoma Consider When Making the Decision to Have Immunotherapy?

Here is advice and thoughts from Weber and Allison this year:  Progress in the Treatment of Advanced Melanoma: Where We Are Now, and Why the Future Is So Promising 

Melanoma gives us no easy answers. Yet, we continue to learn more about the disease and more about how to survive it!!  Hang tough, ratties.  Hang tough. - c